Presenting…The Carrie Diaries
Tuesday, May 18th, 2010The excitement surrounding Sex and the City 2 is mounting as every day goes by – and it’s not just my friends and I who think so. Kristin Davis is on the May cover of Fitness, and Sarah Jessica Parker is on the cover of May’s Vogue and June’s Marie Claire, with a special cover-insert spread in MC that has Davis, Cynthia Nixon, Kim Cattrall and Parker all dressed up with a million places to go. I also read recently that bars are prepping themselves for the onslaught of women tottering up to the bar to order their requisite cosmos, and there was an article in the newspaper the other day about a drink that was made in honour of Mr. Big. It’s Sex mania! And here’s me, lovin’ every minute of it, as evidenced by my recent purchase of Candace Bushnell’s teen novel, The Carrie Diaries.
This book gives SATC fans a much-wondered-about look into Carrie’s life before she was spending upwards of $500 on a single pair of shoes. The Carrie Diaries even takes place before, to quote Stanford, “she rode the subway and wore Candies.” Instead, this is high school in the ’80s, and Carrie is a fledgling, closet writer, a girl whose unique fashion sense is touched on but not made a focal point, a young woman whose hair we don’t even find out is curly! But, Carrie is also someone with a lot of musings about love, life, and the tricky social strata of high school. Not an outcast, but not the most popular girl, either, Carrie’s adolescent life as a senior in high school revolves around her best friends Lali, The Mouse (a.k.a. Roberta), and Maggie – that is, until Sebastian Kydd moves to town and throws everything out of whack in every way possible.
However, between the boredom of life in Carrie’s small-town Connecticut and the ups and downs of her relationship with Sebastian, and then the ultimate disappointment of not only his betrayal but one of her friends’ as well, she comes out on the other side of graduation with the spirit of Carrie intact – and thanks to the book, we get to see how she did it.
OK, sure, that’s all fine and dandy, but at the base level, forget the plot and the story that we’re supposed to talk about, and just think about what you really want to know: Is Carrie in the book Carrie in the show? Huh? Is she? Is she? Well, she is and she isn’t. First let me say that I enjoyed Diaries immensely (isn’t that obvious by now?), and that’s partly because it’s not like Bushnell’s adult novels at all. I read 4 Blondes, and about a quarter of Trading Up, and in both I found the tone too pretentious. Yes, I get that the worlds Bushnell writes about are pretentious ones, but she often portrays those worlds in a way that’s unrelatable to the reader, with what seems like insider quips and upper-classisms that not everyone is going to understand, or even necessarily care about.
But, The Carrie Diaries! I read this book in a day, so all the details of it were fresh and sharp in my mind after each page flip, as were the details of the show that I know so well, because, um, I have large portions of its six seasons memorized – the result of viewing after repeated viewing. Book Carrie versus Show Carrie is a large point of contention, though – just take a quick look at some of the reviews of the book on amazon.com. Most people (read: women) seem to waver between loving the book and forgiving that not every detail is “true” to the Carrie they know from TV (I am of this persuasion), and being supremely annoyed that the details were not followed. This exact gripe was one of the first things I complained to Darcy about, and he responded that Bushnell had no obligation to follow what the show did or said because she’s the one who created the character in the first place. I suppose that’s true, but I think at this point women are more connected to the Carrie from the show than the Carrie from the Sex and the City book, and there’s no going back from that.
So what are the differences causing so much ire? There were three discrepancies I noticed:
1. In the book, Carrie’s father is her and her two sisters’ (yes, Carrie has sisters!) sole provider because their mother died when they were young; in the show, Carrie’s father left her family when she was child.
2. In the book, Carrie is in her last year in high school, and is a virgin; in the show, we know she lost her virginity in high school, on a pool table (smack of gum, and a wink to Charlotte).
3. In the book, Carrie COOKS from a Julia Child cookbook; in the show, she jokes that she uses her oven for storage. (Can you think of an instance when Carrie ever sat down and ate a meal at home, besides when Alex cooks for her there, once?)
Perhaps because of these differences, I felt disassociated with the Carrie I “know,” but this fact didn’t end up bothering me, as I mentioned, because the story was too funny and interesting to dismiss, and because it was set in high school, it was relatable in so many ways. The Carrie Diaries was a fun read made all the better by the end of the book, when Carrie goes to New York City for the first time to take part in a summer writing program before she goes to college at Brown in the fall. The closing dialogue exchange, specifically the last two words, literally made me slam the book shut, squeal with delight, and yell, “I can’t wait until the next one!!!” Darcy then proceeded to make motions and sound effects like my head was exploding. Buy and read The Carrie Diaries so yours can do the same!





