Vegan onion rings – yep, they exist
Monday, March 28th, 2011Never in my wildest dreams did I think I would be cooking my own onion rings, let alone taking on vegan ones, but here I am, blogging loud and proud. If you’ve been following De Facto Redhead’s kitchen adventures this month, you’ll know that my partner in all things culinary, Ami, has gone completely vegan for the entire month of March, so after the success of last week’s vegan chocolate peanut-butter cups, I showed my support again by also “going vegan” for Week 7′s onion rings. We were both really pumped up about this recipe. Said with much exclamation this week were such things as: “huge onion ring fan!” “we love onion rings!” and “I’m excited!” Here is the Post Punk Kitchen recipe that had us so worked up:
INGREDIENTS
2 Vidalia onions (about a pound), or other sweet onion like Walla Walla
1/2 cup plus 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour
2 tablespoons corn starch
1 cup cold almond milk
1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar
1 cup whole wheat bread crumbs
1 teaspoon kosher salt
2 teaspoons olive oil
Cooking spray
DIRECTIONS
Slice onions into 3/4-inch-thick rings. Separate the rings and place in a bowl. Cover with a kitchen towel or something, to keep the onioniness out of your eyes.
Preheat oven to 450 F. Line a rimmed 12×18 baking sheet with parchment paper, spray with cooking spray, and set aside.
Now you’ll need two bowls for batter and breading. If you’ve got large, wide cereal bowls, that’ll do the trick. In one bowl, dump in the flour and corn starch. Add about half of the almond milk and stir vigorously with a fork to dissolve. Add the rest of the almond milk and the apple cider vinegar, and stir to incorporate. Set aside.
In the other bowl, mix together the bread crumbs and salt. Drizzle in the oil and use your fingertips to mix it up well.
Assemble the onion rings:
Get a conveyor belt going. From left to right, have the onions, the flour mixture, the bread-crumbs mixture and, lastly, the baking sheet. Dip each onion slice into the flour, letting the excess drip off. Transfer to the bread-crumbs bowl, and use the other hand to sprinkle a handful of bread crumbs over the onion, to coat completely. This may take a bit of practice. Carefully transfer each onion to a single layer on the baking sheet. Make sure you use one hand for the wet batter and the other for the dry batter, or you’ll end up with club hand.
Spray rings lightly with cooking spray, and bake for 8 minutes. Flip, and bake for another 6 minutes. Rings should be varying shades of brown and crisp. Taste one to check for doneness. Serve as soon as possible.
My onion-ring-ready ingredients.
Ami’s onion-ring-ready ingredients.
My onion rings, ready to be oven-baked until brown and crispy.
Ami’s onion rings, pre-baking and post-battering.
My supper – not just your regular greasy burg ‘n’ rings.
Ami’s rings, looking well-plated and perfectly placed!
Ami made her onion rings before me this week, and by the time I finished reading her “review” e-mail, I was feeling a little less “excited” about tackling the recipe. Why? Well, she started out with these enthusiastic and motivating words: “So, I made the onion rings tonight. They were all right. Definitely my least favorite of all the recipes so far.” Uh-oh – our first failure? Let’s start from the beginning, with the ingredients.
- I didn’t make any substitutions, but Ami used rice milk instead of almond milk (for no other reason than that’s what she had in her fridge), and she used arrowroot flour/starch in place of corn starch because it’s less processed and easier to digest.
- I had never heard of a “Walla Walla” onion before, and since I couldn’t find a specifically labelled “Vidalia” onion bin, I just used regular ol’ sweet onions. Neither Ami nor I used the entire two onions – some rings broke, and others were too small, etc. – but there was still plenty to go around as a side dish for two people.
- I wasn’t sure where to find whole wheat bread crumbs, and Ami suggested Bulk Barn. Success!
- I also thought apple cider vinegar was going to be a challenge to locate (simply because I had never heard of it before), but finding it was laughably easy, considering I bought it at Walmart.
- A personal note about my salt (pictured above) that I know you’ll find thrilling (like, head-explosion thrilling) – it came with Darcy and I from Edmonton! Go, salt! You da bomb!
Next up, Ami and I criticize the cooking directions:
- “Separate the rings and place in a bowl. Cover with a kitchen towel or something, to keep the onioniness out of your eyes.” Neither of us did this. What was the point? All the work of slicing and separating took place on the cutting board, and there wasn’t really a way to avoid the “onioniness,” towel or no.
- “Add about half of the almond milk and stir vigorously with a fork to dissolve.” Ami had issues with clumping in this step, and after stirring for five minutes, gave up. Her worry was that the lumps had something to do with her substitutions. I have to say there might be some truth to that. I used almond milk and corn starch, and my flour/milk mixture was completely clump-free.
- “…bake for 8 minutes. Flip, and bake for another 6 minutes.” And here we have the biggest discrepancy. In order to get her rings to a crispier crispiness, Ami had to bake them for about 20-22 minutes in total. She wondered if it was just her oven that caused the time difference. Nope. I completely agree with her, so unless BOTH our ovens are faulty, we recommend baking your onions rings for at least 20 minutes, and then keeping an eye on them for browning and crispiness. (I also broiled mine on high for the last minute of baking, and I would do that for longer, next time.) Leaving the rings in for the 14 minutes the recipe recommended would have left them soggy and blech.
And now, for the final product…
- Some of Ami’s key words were “dry,” “crumbly,” and “decent-enough,” and her rating was a 2.5 out of 5. Her most damning sentence, though, was this: “…with a little ketchup I could ALMOST fool myself into thinking they were the real thing, if I closed my eyes. I just can’t give them a higher rating, though. I am of the mindset that healthy food (even vegan and vegetarian) should still be yummy and satisfy your cravings…these just fell short for me.” Ouch. I do agree with Ami that the onion rings were dry (I likened certain bites to sawdust in my mouth), but I felt they were worth eating for what I thought was the delicious sweetness of the baked onion. And, not ALL the rings were dry – the ones that managed to crisp up well were pretty good. Therefore, my rating is 3.5 out of 5, which takes into account my comments above, as well as the fact that there is room for improvement (i.e. CRISPIER, CRISPIER, CRISPIER!).
- Another note of mine is to not take lightly that the recipe says to “serve as soon as possible.” These wily onion rings cool down fast, and by the end of my meal, any rings I had left were cold, which was kind of disappointing.
- An observation from both Ami and I: men seem to enjoy this recipe. Chris liked the onion rings, and told Ami he would eat them again; Darcy delighted in the onion rings, seemed impressed that they turned out looking like they did, and asked me to make them again the next day! (I didn’t, but I will try them again as an alternative to our staple side of homemade sweet-potato fries.)
So, what about you? Are you intrigued by the temperamental vegan onion rings? Will you try them? Let us know!

























